Provocative Rachel

Provocative Rachel

dontbeprovokedRachel Maddow’s misleading account of East Africa’s recent terrorist attacks contributes to America’s rearming against the War on Terror, despite her better intentions.

On her show Tuesday night, Rachel sort of concluded as I hope many others do that we should not overreact to the recent beheadings of two American journalists.

Her analysis that terror succeeds when it provokes is spot on. And the relatively simple act of murdering two people, however gruesome it was albeit they were journalists and Americans, is about as provocative as you can get.

But in elaborating on the “gruesome” and “provocative” Rachel fell down that slippery slope so American of defining a situation worse than it really is, of exaggeration. Fear does this. It moves you to overreact.

In describing the abject brutality of al-Shabaab, she recounted incompletely the bar bombing in Kampala in July, 2010, and followed that with a similarly misleading recounting of the Westgate Mall attack in September, 2013.

(Al-Shabaab claimed responsibility for both attacks, although to this day it’s not completely clear the militant group held complete authority regarding Westgate. That tight knit group of terrorists who carried out the attack were mostly foreign and may have included the “White Widow”, no underling to Somali warlords who might aspire to be her boss.)

Rachel implied that both were indiscriminate if not random killings. This couldn’t be further from the truth. It doesn’t in any way justify them, but it does help to explain why they happened.

The first motivation for both is that the Ugandan and Kenyan armies viciously fought al-Shabaab. The Ugandans were the lead army in the UN so-called peace-keeping force that had been battling al-Shabaab for years in Somalia.

The Kenyan Army staged a much, much greater assault in October, 2011, a virtual invasion supplied, organized and probably managed from start to finish by America. The Kenya Army remains a significant occupier of Somalia.

The second specific motivation for the Kampala bombing was that it was in a bar of people watching the World Cup: recreation and alcohol. A bombing of that magnitude would have been far more devastating had it occurred in the central bus station or airport.

More to the point, however, it would have been far easier at the bus station or a dozen other places than in a security patrolled, modern sports bar.

The second specific motivation for the Westgate bombing was the decadence of a mall which on the Muslim holy day had something like a mini rock concert, and as with all the malls in Kenya, sold everything from liquor to ladies panties. Why Westgate in particular? Because it is the only mall of Kenya’s giant three owned by a Jew.

So it is not completely random, and as I said, that hardly makes it better or more justified. Rather I’m saying there’s method in this madness.

Rachel then described the failed Navy Seals operation two weeks after the Westgate Mall attack which attempted to take out one of the leaders of al-Shabaab. We got him with a later drone attack, and Rachel then pointed out how easily he was replaced.

I’ve written a lot about Westgate and terrorism. It’s hard to exaggerate the brutality of ISIS, yet we do. We do by failing to compare it with all the other homicides and murders and unnatural deaths and lack of simple human rights right in our own backyard.

We all exaggerate, as Rachel did, by considering the most horrible of acts random. They are, in fact, rarely random. If subtle, the world’s terrorists are very methodical. Their horrific acts, including suicide bombings, are cleverly and carefully designed to entrap us.

Exaggeration is knee-jerk. It leads us into wars. We take the bait of provocation.

Unfortunately, we’ve learned to if not forget, to file distantly away in an instant afterwards the senseless murder of a kid in Ferguson or the senseless murder of an employee in a gun range in Nevada.

Perhaps we nurture such forgetfulness so that we can retrieve the events later on, in calmer moments, when we are fitter to analyze them better, to determine less emotionally if new actions are called for.

So we should now do with the senseless murders of two journalists.

Bloody Red Cross

Bloody Red Cross

redcrosscallsformilitaryWhen the Kenyan Red Cross demands military action, you know the world has changed.

It’s been a rough week for the purveyor of humanitarian relief. First there was the kerfuffle in The Ukraine where Vladimir told the white crosses to move it or lose it. Then yesterday a Red Cross ambulance in northern Kenya was attacked and destroyed, its occupants barely escaping with their lives.

It didn’t take Kenyan Red Cross officials long to then demand that President Kenyatta send in the army.

“It is now time to act,” Abbas Gullet, secretary-general of the Kenya Red Cross Society (KRCS), told IRIN yesterday.

Gullet was referring to a June 25 pledge by the Kenyan president to send in the Army if the tribal groups in this part of northeastern Kenya didn’t stop fighting.

They didn’t stop fighting.

What’s happening in around this far northern city of Mandera in Kenya is exactly what’s happening in many places in the world, like Pakistan and Myanmar, when hostile ethnic groups get their hands on heavy weapons.

How do they get the weapons?

Don’t make me laugh. Watch Nicholas Cage in Lord of War. It’s cheaper and easier to buy an AK47 in Mandera, Kenya, than it is to buy a sack of potatoes.

And after you’ve killed enough merchants and collected enough coins, just hop over the Somali or Ethiopian border for the Labor Day Sale of grenade launchers.

Soon everyone is killing everyone. Kill or get killed.

Those groups most successful attract the attention of stronger military powers. They make the first compromises of their lives, to join forces however temporarily with other similar groups, and they become the new terrorist threat in the region.

From time immemorial ethnic rivalries existed worldwide and were violent. Development and education ameliorates the hatred and bloodshed subsides when productive work develops.

Global warming, which especially in this part of northeastern Kenya adjacent Somali means more and worse droughts, followed by sudden and terrible floods, makes things worse.

Slow development is often worse than no development at all. People’s hopes are raised then dashed.

This is northern Kenya in a nutshell. It is much of the rest of the world, too.

“Our mission is to work with vigor and compassion … to prevent and alleviate human suffering and save lives of the most vulnerable,” the Kenyan Red Cross charter says.

So… stand your ground boys, then fire!!

Labor Day

Labor Day

Today is the Labor Day holiday in the United States. America’s May Day.

Labor Day is traditionally the end of summer when friends and family gather for the last summer barbecue. It vies with Christmas and New Years to be the least worked day of the U.S. year.

Vacations end, schools reopen, the fall sports season begins particularly American football, the culture season begins in the great cities especially operas and symphonies, and everyone piles back to work.

Many species of birds are flying through and many of our own species are readying to leave. The wild turkey are eating madly to beef up for winter. Deer fawn are grown and losing their spots. Our pet dogs are shedding handfuls of hair all over the place.

Where I live in the Driftless Area near the Mississippi River in the Upper Midwest, the great green forests are beginning to change color. Soon there will be piles of yellow and red leaves where now there are only patches. The sumac are a deep red, elm turn yellow, maple become blood red and oak a warm, deep orange.

Many species of birds are flying through going south and many of our own species like the hummingbird and red-winged blackbird are readying to leave. Shots can be heard along the great Mississippi as hunters try to get some of the migrating ducks.

Days shorten. Right now we have 13 hours of sunlight, but that’s shrinking by nearly 3 minutes a day until December 21 when we’ll have less than 9 hours.

And we all know that right around the corner the leafless forest will be covered in snow.