Terror in Somalia/Fear in Kenya

Terror in Somalia/Fear in Kenya

Kenyan police at the border post at Mandera with Somalia say villagers are fleeing the fighting leaving only a "ghost town."
Kenyan police say fighting in Somalia has turned the Kenyan border post at Mandera into a ghost town.
Fighting on the Kenyan border with Somalia does not mean Kenya’s stability is further threatened, but it does mean we better start paying more attention to Somalia.

The bold bombing in what had been a stable part of Mogadishu, today, and which killed several government ministers as well as a dozen graduating university students and several journalists, finally catapulted the Somali conflict into the world media, again. According to Google this morning, there were nearly 500 major media stories about the blast, second on the day only to news about Afghanistan.

This major escalation of the terribly complex and horribly bloody Somali conflict comes less than a week after a major battle between two Somali factions temporarily spilled over the Kenyan border at Mandera. This was the second such incident in a month. In October, fierce battles spilled over the border town of Dhobley, about one hundred miles south of Mandera.

Kenyan Internal Security permanent secretary, Francis Kimemia, confirmed Tuesday that Al-Shabaab rebels had captured the border towns opposite Mandera during a weekend of fierce fighting with the rival clan, Hizbul. Kimemia was then quick to say the conflict had been contained in Somalia.

Kenya has many troops and police in this near desert area in its far northeast where Kenya borders Ethiopia and Somalia. Many UK and U.S. soldiers have been seen here, and some openly in the large Kenyan island city of Lamu from which they stage operations.

The U.S. as well as many experts consider Al-Shabaab to be Al-Qaeda, and it is widely known that despite the U.S. support for the internationally created Somali government in Mogadishu, that the U.S. also supports Hizbul, which is trying to overthrow that central government.

The enemy of my enemy is my friend.

But while Al-Shabaab may be responsible for today’s suicide bombing in Mogadishu, the real battle between Al-Shabaab and Hizbul is for the important southern part of the country which borders Kenya, mainly to control the well developed Somali port of Kismayu. This is the center of Somali piracy, the single largest contributor to this tattered country’s GDP and could easily rival Mogadishu in many respects.

Abdullahi Jamaa of Nairobi’s Daily Nation wrote yesterday, “Somali gunmen often prowl along the borderline and their presence is testimony to the fragile security in much of Kenya’s lengthy border [with Somalia]. Over the years, the worsening situation of Somalia has rendered the security of Mandera all but non-existent. Residents live in fear.”

But most Kenyan officials are not worried that actual fighting will spill over from Somalia, and I agree, at least for the foreseeable future. Rather, there are two other immediate problems.

The first are refugees. The Dhobley battle in October sent as many as 2,000 Somalis fleeing into Kenya. Last weekend’s battle in Mandera sent very few, and that is likely because Al-Shabaab has now consolidated its victory over Hizbul for the whole length of the Kenyan border. But caring even for as few as 2,000 refugees is a great drain on Kenyan resources.

The second problem which Kenyan government officials consider even more daunting is the huge inflow of Somali piracy money into the Kenyan black market.

Internal Security Minister Professor George Saitoti says instability in Somalia had led to colossal sums of (pirate) money coming into Kenya illegally.

“And of course when they come here, it may appear initially that it is good for the economy but sooner or later that kind of money ends up distorting the monetary system and the economy as a whole,” the Minister said at a forum recently attended by U.S. Ambassador to Kenya, Michael Ranneberger.

* * *

I believe that Kenya is too stable to be a goal for Al-Qaeda the way Afghanistan and Somalia definitely are. Kenya is too developed, too modern, too secular. I remember all too well the embassy bombing in August, 1998. The first thing we noticed only hours after the bombing was how the city’s residents had set fire to the city’s main mosque.

In the ten years since then, Kenya’s development and integration into the western world has sped up exponentially. Despite the terrible election violence of December, 2007, the country is currently peaceful and in the context of a world recession, actually prosperous.

But what is happening to Somalia is extremely dangerous, and being aside Kenya it gives us an unique and hopefully more urgent perspective.

If we are successful in Iraq and Afghanistan, and if the Pakistanis are at all successful stabilizing their own country, where will Al-Qaeda go?

Somalia.

Fewer Tourists/Prices Drop

Fewer Tourists/Prices Drop

The first hard indication of how much tourism in East Africa has been effected by the global downturn was revealed, today: Down 25-30%.

The announcement was made by Richard Rugimbana, a spokesman for the Tourism Confederation of Tanzania, during a conference in Dar-es-Salaam this morning.

Tourism numbers are very hard to get from East Africa and are generally skewed by the analyzer to promote a certain position. Earlier this year, for example, the Kenyan Tourist Board claimed that tourism was down only 10%. We all knew this was ludicrous.

I think Rugimbana’s numbers are more likely.

November is generally the latest date that hoteliers and transport operators announce their rates for the following year. EWT’s compilation of rates now shows a general decline of about 10% over the 2009 rates, but in fact, it could be much deeper.

Special offers by a host of hoteliers and local airlines are being constantly extended. These take various forms but the two most popular seem to be a 3- or 4-night stay for the cost of 2- or 3-nights, and an extension of low season rates into higher seasons.

The second form is more substantive and generally results in a discount of a third to a half. It also allows forward strategic marketing. The result is normally a long term rate reduction. We see this happening right now mostly among the smaller companies, although a few larger ones like Serena, are fiddling ever so slightly with the idea.

Anecdotal evidence is supporting a long-term reduction. Fairmont, Sopa, Cheli & Peacock, among many other major players, have been unable to reverse their serious job cuts, and &Beyond is reported to be considering closing indefinitely one of the three wings of Crater Lodge. Serena, which historically has offered very deep discounts for the local market, is reportedly extending a blind eye to foreign resellers paying them at these heavily discounted rates. None of these companies will confirm these rumors, but they are widely known on the street.